“We know this area” is a starting point for a conversation. Before paying for a search, you need to understand whose experience is being described and how it relates to the work you need. This guide provides an original evidence worksheet and a hypothetical comparison for that specific hiring decision.
Start with the person and the work you need
Write down your target area, property type and requested service before comparing experience. A search for a strata apartment and an auction-only engagement ask different things of an agent. Use the buying-brief guide if those requirements are still unclear.
The NSW Fair Trading buyers-agent guide recommends asking about experience in property research and negotiating prices, as well as the service offered. Turn that into a specific discussion: who would inspect, research and negotiate for you, and which examples reflect that person’s own work?
A firm’s combined history may include work by several people. Ask whether the proposed contact led the search, inspected a shortlisted property, negotiated the purchase or only assisted another team member. Useful experience can take different forms; it should be described accurately. Also ask who covers the work if the named person is unavailable.
Compare experience using five questions
| Question | Useful detail to request | Limit to keep in view |
|---|---|---|
| Whose experience is it? | Named person, their role and the tasks they completed. | An agency total does not identify each person’s contribution. |
| How recent and relevant? | Time period, general location, property type and service provided. | There is no purchase-count threshold established by this worksheet. |
| What did the work involve? | A research question, evidence used, uncertainty found and follow-up arranged. | A successful purchase alone does not show the reasoning behind it. |
| What can be checked? | A permissioned example, source reference or client reference arranged with consent. | An unverified account remains an account; private material may be withheld. |
| How does it fit this brief? | What transfers to your search and what needs fresh investigation. | Past work cannot guarantee a future price, access to a property or outcome. |
Use the same questions with each candidate. A recent period such as the past year can make the discussion manageable, but it is your comparison window, not a legal requirement or a pass mark. If relevant examples are older or in nearby areas, ask what is similar, what is different and how the agent would research the gaps.
Ask for an explanation you can follow
Invite the agent to walk through one relevant example without disclosing a client’s identity or confidential instructions. Ask what they needed to establish, which sources they used, what those sources could not tell them and who dealt with the remaining question. A description of the process is more useful when you can separate the agent’s work from a solicitor’s, inspector’s or lender’s work.
For example, an agent might describe identifying an unresolved strata-record question and arranging follow-up. That does not mean the agent personally certified the building or interpreted every legal document. Ask where their service stops and which professional you would need to engage separately.
If a purchase price or sale date is publicly available, it may help check that part of an example. It does not, by itself, establish who represented the buyer, what the client instructed or whether the fee was worthwhile. A missing public sale result also does not prove an account is false; see why a sale may not yet appear in NSW records.
The property research tool guide explains the public-record questions Baxau can help organise. Use those records within their limits. They are not a register of an agent’s clients or proof of that agent’s involvement, and the tool does not provide a valuation or certify a property.
Keep licence checks and references in their proper place
Use the official NSW licence-check guidance to check the person or business you will deal with. It describes licence or certificate categories, conditions, dates and disciplinary information. This checks authorisation details; it does not measure local buying experience. NSW Fair Trading also explains that a certificate holder acting as a buyers agent must work under the direction of a licensed real estate agent.
A testimonial or star rating usually leaves questions unanswered: which person did the work, what service was provided and how closely did that brief resemble yours? Use it to frame follow-up questions. Do not turn a review count into a local-experience ranking or assume that a positive account predicts your result.
If a former client is willing to speak, arrange the introduction through the agent with that client’s consent. Ask about the service received, communication, follow-through and anything they would clarify before engaging again. Do not request their contract, financial position or private correspondence. A selected reference is one person’s account, not a complete record of every engagement.
A hypothetical comparison: detailed evidence versus a headline claim
This example is invented. It is not a review of real agents, a market survey or a recommendation. The buyer wants help searching for a Sydney strata apartment. Both candidates still need the same licence, scope, fee and conflict checks.
| Candidate account | What the buyer can record | Follow-up before deciding |
|---|---|---|
| Candidate A describes many purchases across Sydney but does not identify the proposed contact’s role. | Broad agency experience is claimed; personal involvement and apartment relevance remain unclear. | Ask the proposed contact for a relevant example and their own tasks within it. |
| Candidate B describes a recent apartment search, their inspection and negotiation role, and an unresolved records issue referred for specialist review. | The account is more specific to the brief; its details and the proposed service still need checking. | Request a suitably anonymised example or consented reference, and confirm who will handle this search. |
Candidate B has supplied a clearer account in this example, not proved superior service. Candidate A may be able to fill the gaps. The next step is to resolve the missing information, then compare scope, availability and fees. Neither account supports a claim about guaranteed savings or future off-market access.
Copy this local-experience evidence worksheet
- Your brief: area, property type, requested service and the comparison period you chose.
- Candidate and proposed contact: distinguish the firm from the person doing the work.
- Example described: general location, property type, approximate timing and service.
- Personal role: tasks the proposed contact completed and work handled by others.
- Evidence and provenance: what you saw or heard, who supplied it and when.
- Check status: independently checked detail, candidate account, consented reference, or not established.
- Relevance and limits: what fits your brief and what still needs fresh research.
- Open question and next step: the missing detail, who will respond and the agreed follow-up date.
- Decision reason: continue discussions, seek clarification or stop considering the candidate; do not convert missing information into an accusation.
Keep this worksheet with your own records. General descriptions may be enough; you do not need another buyer’s identifying details. An agent declining to disclose confidential information is not, on its own, evidence of poor service. Ask what alternative explanation or permissioned material they can offer.
Use the evidence to narrow your shortlist
Look for an understandable account of relevant work, clear limits and answers to your outstanding questions. If the service or person remains uncertain, clarify it before signing. The quote-comparison worksheet covers the separate decision about written scope, total fees and payment terms. After engagement, use the search-progress review guide to discuss delivery against the work agreed.
If you would like an introduction, describe the Sydney buyers-agent service you need. Share your own brief, not another client’s records. Baxau may receive a referral fee negotiated case by case; read how introductions work. An introduction does not replace your checks. Explore related questions in the choosing a buyers agent hub.
If you need Mandarin or Cantonese support, also use the Chinese-speaking agent checklist to confirm who provides it, which stages it covers and what needs separate interpreting or translation.